Robert Plant or Randy Jackson?

[Crash N' Ride]

Who do you prefer?

And please don't make this decison based on who took drugs. Base it on talent. Thanks.

Ohh. I can't decide I like em' both. Randy has better range but Plant has AMAZING stage presence and showmanship along with a GREAT voice.

[RandyJ4ever]

God damn!!!! I can't choose!!! I love them both!!! AHHHHH!!!!! Which do I choose!??!! H'mm... I don't think I can. ;)

[PWRChordManiac]

Plant flat out!

[ronbo11]

Percy can't hit the high notes like he used to, but he's still the pinnacle of front men in my estimation....

[ZEBRAFREAK]

IT'S A TIE!!!

[PWRChordManiac]

it's close but I'm going with Plant

[Delirious Nomad]

Plant can't hit the notes that Randy hits.
Can Plant play the guitar while he sings?
Can he play guitar at all?

Going with talent, there's no question.

Randy Jackson

[Crash N' Ride]

Originally posted by Delirious Nomad
Plant can't hit the notes that Randy hits.
Can Plant play the guitar while he sings?
Can he play guitar at all?

Going with talent, there's no question.

Randy Jackson

I was just going for vocal ablility and skill. Not for who has the "most" talent. I was hopeing people would leave the fact that Randy Jackson plays guitar out of this.

Their both amazing, I still can't decide but I lean toward Plant only because after a while screeching vocals give me a headache. But I love randy. Just saying that I choose to listen to Led Zeppelin a lot more than Zebra, and vocals are one of the reasons why.

[Delirious Nomad]

Originally posted by Crash N' Ride


I was just going for vocal ablility and skill. Not for who has the "most" talent. I was hopeing people would leave the fact that Randy Jackson plays guitar out of this.


Sorry,
when you brought up stage presence and showmanship, I saw that we weren't talking about just the voice. Afterall, it's kinda hard to have great stage presence when you're limited to singing into a microphone stand while you play.

Just voice?
Still gotta go with Randy.
:D

[Crash N' Ride]

Originally posted by Delirious Nomad


Sorry,
when you brought up stage presence and showmanship, I saw that we weren't talking about just the voice. Afterall, it's kinda hard to have great stage presence when you're limited to singing into a microphone stand while you play.

Just voice?
Still gotta go with Randy.
:D

Thats my point, it is easier for Randy to have stage presence through his guitar playing. But Robert really has to put more out there and he is amazing at it!

[JJD]

Very close call here but if I were forced to choose, I will go with Randy.

[Ludwig7]

Robert Plant. He was a huge influence on Randy.

[Wakddood]

Randy does a better Plant than Plant. As with most of your older singers, his voice is not what it used to be. Randy still has it after all these years. Randy takes good care of himself and gave up all the bad stuff years ago. Plus noone can hold a note like Randy.

[puffpattiduke]

ditto what wackdood said!!!!! RANDY ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!! :D

[SHOELUVRSIS]

never much of a zep fan to begin with - what am i missing?
Randy all the way for sure!

[RockStorm]

I say Randy & Robert get up on stage together and have a BATTLE OF THE VOICES.........Whose voice cracks first gets to go home with throat lozenges...The winner gets the Jack............KEEP ROCKIN.........

[OURSOOOOO]

Robert Plant Is The Golden Voice Of Rock.
This Is Kinda Like The Randy, Page Discussion,
There Is No Comparison And Randy Will Tell You That. Plant Is Randys Biggest Influence.
As Much Of A Randy Jackson And Zebra Fan That I Am, Randy Is Second Best To A Guy Named Matt Jernigan Of The Zeppelin Tribute Band "Zoso". Check Them Out At The Varsity In Baton Rouge, They Play There About Every Six Months Or So And Then Give Me Your Opinion. This Is The Best Place To See Them. I Have Seen Them In Laf. And N.o. And The Sound ****ed!!!!!!!!!!!!!